Movie Review: If You Want an Explanation for “Mother!” This Is as Close as We Can Get

Darren Aronofsky’ mother! is a shrieking satire not for the faint-hearted, or people of faith, or anyone, maybe?
Have you accepted writer-director Darren Aronofsky as your personal saviour?
If not, good luck justifying mother! to yourself. The ads and posters play up the mystery, insisting you go knowing nothing and soak in its mind-boggling, earth-shattering weirdness. This feels like a failure in duty of care. Will they set up trauma tents outside the cinema?
But I understand the strategy of silence. Fact is, there’s no way to talk about mother! without ruining its big reveal (which emerges within the first 10 minutes, becomes Gospel halfway through, and then explodes with face-smushing obviousness in its gonzo final act). If you’re already a fan of Aronofsky’s other frenzied exercises—Black Swan, Pi, Requiem for a Dream—mother! is a safe-ish space to go in blind.
Undecided? Mild spoilers below. They could save your life, or, at the very least, your next date night at the movies.
mother! opens on Javier Bardem, credited only as ‘Him’, wrestling with writer’s block in an isolated country manor he shares with his nameless wife (Jennifer Lawrence). She’s renovated the house with precise, maternal care, which makes her especially nervy when two messy randoms turn up at their welcome mat. (Andrew Weisblum’s jittery editing is occasionally paused by long takes of Lawrence anxiously wandering from room to room, to lull you into thinking this is just going to be a typical home-invasion thriller. It ain't.)
First comes a stranger (Ed Harris), who fawns over Bardem’s work as a poet. Second is the stranger’s wife (a rowdy Michelle Pfeiffer), who only pops up after Harris endures a slice near his rib. Him, newly struck with creative inspiration, keeps telling his wife to pour drinks (aka ‘playing mother’) and politely appreciate the company of their overbearing houseguests. She complies, for a while.
You may already see where this is going.
Anyone with a passing familiarity with the Old Testament will lock into Aronofsky’s allegory when the strangers’ violent, feuding sons infiltrate the house. Later, obsessive fans and followers of ‘Him’ trample through the door, carelessly mangling their home, repainting it and fornicating in every corner, over Lawrence’s protests. And as the New Testament eventually starts playing out in gory detail, you may not so much wonder what’s going on as why, and how a major American studio agreed to spend $30 million on it.

So, is Bardem portraying God as a gaslighting artist with a misogynistic streak? Or is he Aronofsky, with the filmmaker parodying his own self-seriousness? (Muddying things: Aronofsky and Lawrence are an item in real life.) Is the shoeless Lawrence taking the guise of Mother Nature herself, acquiescent at first to human infiltration, before revolting ferociously at their climate-harming ways? Or is she Mother Mary? Or, is she the Hollywood actress who suffers at the whims of her cruel male director? (Suffers, she does.)
And are all these rhetorical questions an easy way out of landing on one side or another of the fence? It’d be a cop-out to equivocate about such a brazen art picture, but mother! truly is all of the above, even though its narrative very specifically follows the Bible’s greatest hits. After Noah, it’s both an unsurprising and totally shocking move by Aronofsky, with one scene in particular acting as a brutal critique of Christianity (and zealotry in general). I won’t spoil it, but, yeah, Holy Communion won’t ever be the same.
Not only does mother! tear at the fabric of religion with a feverish rage, it commits the sin—for some viewers—of casting Lawrence (she of Winter’s Bone, The Hunger Games and Silver Linings Playbook) against type as a demure, anxious and often-voiceless woman. And yet, she’s a perfect fit for Aronofsky, whose films are pitched to the point of hysteria from minute one, and build. She's not an over-the-top actress, but she often shines when her characters boil over. Finally, a project that not only calls for this skill, but giddily screams for it, often to comical effect.
The last thing you'd accuse Aronofsky of is intentional comedy, but I'm also hesitant to say a man who puts an enthusiastic exclamation mark at the end of his title (which comes with a chipper 'ding' as it appears on screen) is entirely stone-faced, despite the proof of his previous efforts. (Lone exception: The Wrestler, a wonderfully empathetic dramedy, in which he, of course, kills the hero.) When absurdity takes over in the final third—and cinematographer Matthew Libatique’s dreamy camera becomes a roaming guide through the house’s hellish horrors—mother! becomes wildly fun and certainly unforgettable.
Sure, I enjoyed the act of watching mother! unfold, but does it work? Ehhhh. The central metaphor goes beyond the subtextual to become literal text, making it hard to appreciate as a commentary rather than a bonkers biblical adaptation which will be seen by few and appreciated by fewer. You can't celebrate a twisted horror flick for being ‘sneakily political’ when it is literally preaching to the converted (and already patting itself on the back).
Then again, as a vision, it’s uncompromised, and those are few and far between. It also succeeds in becoming the second 2017 feature to make viewers actively root against humanity’s survival.
3.5/5
In cinemas now. Rated MA15+ for strong themes, violence and coarse language.
Photo: Paramount Pictures
Topics
Ref: fdd372d6-c808-47bf-9947-a7f2002ea8ef
Most Popular
Comments & Feedback
Share your opinion







No Comments just yet
Check back later to see what others are saying , or you can be the first to leave a comment!