Movie Review: A Tiny Matt Damon Stars in Disposable Climate Change Comedy “Downsizing”

Downsizing, starring a small-in-stature Matt Damon, gives short shrift to its many big ideas.
Alexander Payne’s new film is about the end of the world. And it’s about climate change. And immigration. And human trafficking. And class struggle. And marital dissatisfaction. And existential stasis. And the danger of unregulated technological advancement without moral consideration.
But it’s mostly about people getting shrunk down to five-inch versions of themselves as a cost-cutting measure. And it’s a comedy. And a drama. And a dystopian sci-fi flick. And it’s… a lot.
Written by director Payne and his frequent collaborator Jim Taylor, it follows his spiky road movie Nebraska, though its closest companion is The Descendants, that earnest, sullen, misjudged George Clooney dramedy he made in 2011. Needless to say, this isn’t Payne’s optimal speed. Despite a few scattered moments of ferocious comedy, the pointed satire of Citizen Ruth and Election has been watered down, leaving us with an Albert Brooksian, hands-across-the-globe message movie with an incongruous nihilistic streak.
If it sounds like Downsizing will leave you in an emotional pretzel, it probably won’t. Soon after leaving the theatre, it had largely exited my memory. Payne pages through an encyclopaedia's worth of ideas, settings and characters at a clip, yet at 135 minutes, it’s still too long.
Its moments of hilarity are little comfort. There’s so much going on, there’s just nothing solid to grasp.

In it, Matt Damon and Kristen Wiig play Paul and Audrey Safranek, dissatisfied Omahans with a modest home and few future prospects. When Norwegian scientists develop a way to save the overpopulating planet by shrinking its inhabitants, the Safraneks entertain the idea of getting small to help Mother Earth. Well, actually, they’re tempted by the financial benefits: When you’re 13cm tall, it only costs a couple thousand dollars to live in a (to scale) mansion. Food costs, similarly, plummet.
However, once inside the teensy retirement resort of “Leisureland”, we see that the issues of the “big” world haven’t gone away. They’ve got a class problem and discrimination too. And, in their own tiny way, the shrunken are helping to speed up Earth’s very own Ragnarok. (In its most cutting and all-to-brief moments, the characters ponder what happens to society when a good part of the tax-paying population disappears, although, if that’s what you’re after, I’d point you to The Leftovers instead).
Ngoc Lan (Hong Chau) is one such victim of downsizing; an assertive Vietnamese dissident de-heightened against her will and stuck working as a housecleaner for Paul’s unusually wealthy friend Dusan (an on-brand Christoph Waltz). Chau is a gift to the picture, offering a disenfranchised voice to remind us that the Safraneks’ ordeal doesn’t amount to a hill of beans by comparison.
That voice is also going to be Downsizing’s biggest point of contention. Though Chau is very funny and affecting, her character’s broken English is often used for laughs. Having come from a family of (Italian) immigrants, I know there’s plenty of value to the stories of those with an uneasy grasp of the English language—don’t erase them. Buuut in my screening alone, I heard patrons repeating and mocking Ngoc Lan’s pronunciation of certain lines in a manner that felt icky; as if she was the joke. For that, do we blame the audience, or is the cruelty baked into the script?
So, I’m torn, and I look forward to hearing and reading reviews by those of Vietnamese descent. (Of course, I’m aware the reviewing community is largely lily white.) Will they see Ngoc Lan as a suitable standard-bearer, or another of pop culture’s deflating punchlines?
What a shame that Payne and Taylor hobbled their own movie’s best, most distinctive element. No, I’m not talking about their ‘shrunken’ world (admittedly, it is imaginative and produces plenty of laughs). I’m talking about their brilliant non-white hero, who so easily steals the film from the milquetoast Damon, with complications.
2.5/5
In cinemas Boxing Day. Rated M for sexual references, coarse language, drug use and nudity.
Photo: Paramount Pictures
Topics
Ref: ffbf6372-2db6-45af-bdc8-a834008fb872
Most Popular
Comments & Feedback
Share your opinion







No Comments just yet
Check back later to see what others are saying , or you can be the first to leave a comment!