What Happens If Clive Palmer Wins the Bid to Bring Down WA's Borders?

What Happens If Clive Palmer Wins the Bid to Bring Down WA's Borders?

Let's break it down.

Over the past couple of months, you have probably been hearing a lot about mining billionaire Clive Palmer's legal challenge to bring down Western Australia's hard border. 

At the moment, WA's borders are closed due to the coronavirus pandemic, and people are not allowed to enter the state unless they're considered an essential traveller.

Mr Palmer has been critical of the WA government's decision to shut its borders, sparking a war of words with Premier Mark McGowan. He said he was denied entry to the state back in May, after WA shut its borders the previous month. Mr Palmer claimed he wanted to visit WA for business and political meetings, including one with Senator Mathias Cormann.

Although, it has now been revealed that Mr Palmer never applied for an exemption to the hard border closure. Instead, he left it up to his pilot who made errors on the document.

Regardless, Mr Palmer lodged a document with the High Court, arguing that WA's border closure is unconstitutional. Let's just say, it hasn't been a popular move:

So, what would happen if Mr Palmer won the legal challenge to reopen WA's borders? 

Okay, so what is the legal basis for the challenge?

Basically, section 92 of the Australian constitution allows for free movement of people and trade between states. 

Therefore, Mr Palmer is arguing that not permitting him to travel to WA is a breach of his constitutional rights.

In fact, WA isn't the first state Mr Palmer has challenged. He also challenged Queensland's decision to keep its borders closed, but dropped his court action after the state reopened its borders on 10 July to everyone except those from Victoria and Greater Sydney. 

As reported by the ABC, Mr Palmer said shutting the borders threatens the economy. 

Mr Palmer's legal challenge commenced in the Federal Court last week to determine the facts of the case, and the final decision is expected to be made in the High Court later this year.

Has Mr Palmer got any support? 

The federal government initially supported Mr Palmer's case earlier in the week while it was being heard in the Federal Court, but Australian Prime Minister Scott Morrison withdrew from the legal challenge on Sunday.

It was recently revealed that the Prime Minister wrote to WA Premier Mark McGowan to inform him that he's shifting his position, predominately because of the worsening situation in Victoria.

However, Mr McGowan is concerned that the damage has already been done. 

"I thank the Prime Minister for listening to Western Australians and taking on my advice, I just hope it's not too late in the legal process," he wrote in a Facebook post. 

In the letter, Mr Morrison said, "I consider, on balance, that we must set aside the normal convention in these circumstances and not continue the Commonwealth's participation in this case." 

"Decisions taken early in the outbreak of the pandemic were made with the best intentions and in necessary haste," he added.

"I stress the Commonwealth raised no objections to these actions, however, did note the risk that constitutional issues would arise at a later time." 

Could Mr Palmer actually win the legal challenge?

Yeah, he could. 

The Prime Minister has predicted that the border challenge will not fall in the WA government's favour. 

Earlier this month, Mr Morrison said in Canberra, "I do fear an all-or-nothing approach on the case is not the best way forward because I think the constitutional position is fairly clear." 

"My concern is that it is highly likely that the constitutional position that is being reviewed in this case will not fall in the Western Australian government's favour." 

What will happen if Mr Palmer wins?

At this stage, it's not entirely clear what restrictions the WA government will implement if Mr Palmer wins the legal challenge. 

As reported by PerthNow, Mr McGowan told reporters that the state would have to move to a "plan B" if the court challenge proves successful. 

"We'll go to plan B if we lose. We'll look at whatever we can do to protect people," he said.

States like Queensland have opened their borders to states and territories except for Victorian residents and residents of Greater Sydney. There's always the chance that WA could look at introducing similar measures. 

WA is currently in Phase 4 of relaxing coronavirus restrictions, and the removal of the state's hard border with the rest of the country was supposed to be introduced in Phase 6. 

Additionally, based on the latest health advice, Phase 5 of the COVID-19 roadmap has been delayed until Saturday 15 August. Of course, this could change depending on the evolving situation in Victoria.

Header Image: Stefan Postles / Stringer / Getty Images News via Getty Images

Most Popular

Comments & Feedback

Share your opinion

Emoji cheatsheet    Formatting    Comment guidelines