Should We Watch The Melbourne Cup?

Upon reading this writing challenge question, I wondered: How do I feel about the Melbourne Cup?

While part of me loves the fizz and fascinators that comes with the spectacle, my celebratory get-up has been somewhat hampered in recent years since learning of the “dark side” of the event.

As an animal-friendly individual, I do struggle to get past the stress the horses may endure for this event. I know not all horses are mistreated and I understand it is “the name of the game”, as some people may suggest; however, it does play on my conscience somewhat while I’m sitting in front of the track or TV screen, champers in-hand and fascinator adorned, that perhaps the horses aren’t exactly loving the experience.

It’s a hard decision to come by as it does make one feel quintessentially un-Australian to declare they find the Melbourne Cup a little outdated. The excitement of the race is certainly contagious and the betting that goes with it is just a bit of fun (for most people), but when you hear horrors of stress so severe that horses have a heart attack from the event, or that some are euthanised post-race, one must consider how their actions help support something that isn’t entirely ethical.

I understand for every point I’ve made there are a hundred to counter it. This is why, ultimately, it comes down to personal opinion; your worldview and your ethical standards should dictate whether or not you watch.

Personally, I can no longer endorse the event. Yes, I often have to attend a luncheon or event as to not appear a “stick in the mud” or because I have to for work, but I don’t bet and I don’t indulge in anything that requires me promoting the whole thing.

It is just difficult in today’s society to escape it without coming across like a raging activist and ruining it for everyone else. So what’s the modern day answer? I have no idea! I do not possess the credentials to suggest alternatives, although I’m pretty sure most animal rights groups would suggest canning it altogether.

I’m still hoping we can find a healthy alternative that lands squarely in the middle and can help to continue an Aussie tradition while maintaining the safety of its animal participants.

So, while I don’t believe we should watch the Melbourne Cup, until further notice I guess we all will. Here’s to hoping…

Congratulations to Melissa for winning this writing challenge, answering: Should We Watch The Melbourne Cup? Melissa wins a $50 Westfield gift card for her submission. For your chance to win, check out our latest writing challenges in our Comps section. Also, be sure to follow this guide on how to win the writing challenge!