Movie Review: "Toy Story 4" Plays It Again

Do the tear ducts finally run dry?
Toy Story 4 isn’t the first Toy Story to include a child’s plaything that has turned criminally insane from neglect. It’s not even the first to feature deranged villains who rely on toy-modification surgery for their own disturbed gratification.
This is the first Toy Story flick you’d call inessential.
I remember sitting in the cinema for Toy Story 3, close to a decade ago, sharing in the communal primal scream therapy induced by its incinerator-based climax. It was followed by a relieving, cathartic goodbye between college-age toy owner Andy and his sentient plastic pals Woody, Buzz, Jessie and the rest. It inspired happy-sad wails. It suggested bittersweet finality. For a while, anyway. Now we have Toy Story 4, which hangs off the trilogy like a phantom limb. It’s funny and fun, but it serves no real purpose, much like Woody the cowboy, voiced by Tom Hanks, who finds himself here ignored by Bonnie, the little girl to whom Andy donated all his toys. Problem is, Woody can’t take a clue. And neither can the Toy Story saga.
It’s telling that Bonnie’s favourite new toy is actually a spork she breathed life into at kindergarten simply by adding pipe-cleaner arms and googly eyes (creating a haunted visage). Christened 'Forky' and played by the nervy Tony Hale from Arrested Development and Veep, he spends much of the film trying to return to the sweet embrace of the rubbish bin. A sin against nature, he too knows he shouldn’t be and yet is. Similarly, Toy Story 4 shouldn’t be, and yet…

Okay, okay, Toy Story 4 is perfectly fine. Even good! The quality controllers at Pixar wouldn’t let anything less squeeze through the studio's sausage-maker. However, as we’ve increasingly documented, Pixar is no longer the realm of perfection as it once was. Kids and adults alike will no doubt enjoy TS4 (provided the adults can put aside complaints made by former screenwriter Rashida Jones, who left the project saying Pixar fostered a "culture where women and people of colour do not have an equal creative voice," or that John Lasseter, who exited Pixar in disgrace, still owns a 'story by' credit—though, maybe adults shouldn’t). It just lacks the 'essential' nature of the previous instalments, and it fails to clear the high bar set by Pixar's golden era.
The narrative engine here, credited primarily to screenwriters Stephany Folsom and Andrew Stanton, depends on Bonnie’s family taking the toys on a road trip. When Forky makes one of his many kamikaze jumps out of the moving RV, Woody jumps too, and on the road he runs into old flame Bo Peep (voiced by Annie Potts). With her new Sarah Connor-style outfit, she’s more of a self-sufficient action heroine these days than a shepherdess, living happily among "lost toys". They include delightful new additions like Keanu Reeves’ Canadian stunt-toy Duke Caboom; Ally Maki as spunky, tiny cop Giggle McDimples; and a reuniting Keegan Michael-Key and Jordan Peele as fluffy Ducky and Bunny. Bo invites Woody to stick with them, but he’s on a mission to bring Forky to Bonnie. This is despite the fact Forky is being held hostage by '50s era Gabby Gabby (Christina Hendricks) in an antique store, where she hopes Woody will return to be stripped for parts.

In many ways, it’s a bridging sequel, spending far more time with the newly created characters rather than any of the old favourites. Tim Allen’s pleasantly boneheaded Buzz Lightyear and Joan Cusack’s spirited Jessie are sadly given short shrift. Director Josh Cooley and his animators’ wizardry orchestrate some beautiful sequences, and the voice performers all do exceptionally charming work (Potts especially, getting hers after being excluded for TS3). It’s just that the scope of the story feels so small, when previous entries made the toys’ little world seem so big, and their emotional connections—to each other, and their kids—so meaningful.
Dragging out the Toy Story saga is ignoring Toy Story 4’s central message: sometimes kids want something new; something they can call their own. Maybe future generations will embrace Woody’s new friends, while the rest of us slowly sit out the inevitable follow-ups and TV spin-offs that come down the line. Is this a good thing? A bad thing? Something in between? What’s undeniable is that at the ripe old age of 24, Toy Story is suddenly what it never used to be: disposable.
3.5/5
In Australian cinemas 20 June. Rated G, as some scenes may scare very young children.
Header Image: Disney
Topics
Ref: c4d12d1c-85da-4a05-9f89-aa6c00263f08
Most Popular
Comments & Feedback
Share your opinion







No Comments just yet
Check back later to see what others are saying , or you can be the first to leave a comment!