Movie Review: "Tag" Is 'Not It' and by 'It' I Mean 'Watchable'

Movie Review: "Tag" Is 'Not It' and by 'It' I Mean 'Watchable'

Not everything needs to be a movie, okay?

Tag dramatises (and I’m being very generous with the language of cinema here) the true story of several mates who’ve been playing chasey for literal decades. Before the closing credits, you get to see footage of the lengths these friends go to ensnare and evade one another. Cute. You know, for them.

While that tradition may make for a particularly delightful Twitter Moment, or a temporarily distracting series of Instagram Stories, turning it into a feature-length flick is a bit of a stretch.

And yet, stretch the makers of Tag did! First-time feature director Jeff Tomsic and screenwriters Rob McKittrick and Mark Steilen have taken the inoffensive bones of this decades-spanning game and populated it with grating, half-baked characters, sent sprawling in a torturous psychological maze of their own making. By the end, I was lamenting the fact they weren’t all playing 'Hot Lava' instead, and over actual hot lava.

The leads—Ed Helms, Jon Hamm, Jake Johnson, Hannibal Buress and Jeremy Renner—have each been good, funny and/or likeable in other projects, so what went wrong? They mostly seem to enjoy one another’s company on screen, and I’ll forgive the jarring disconnect of seeing Buress as the high school contemporary of Hamm and Renner, despite the 12-year age difference. Their characters, however, are all detestable in their own ways.

I was particularly creeped out by the manner in which Hamm’s successful businessman, Bob, twice puts his hand on the shoulder of a journalist (Annabelle Wallis) who’s profiling him, almost immediately after meeting her and explaining this game of tag he’s infernally doomed to participate in. (Devil’s advocate: Bob’s psyche is so mangled by all the tagging, he subconsciously 'tags' strangers. If so, weird choice!) Later, the journo casually joins Bob for a cross-country trip to document their latest round, and passively watches his pals kidnap and almost waterboard a gym manager for information on their most elusive player. Sounds like it'll be a fun story.

The picture opens with Helms’ character, Hogan, taking a job as a janitor to surprise—and tag—Bob at work. His reason? The never-been-tagged Jerry (Renner) is retiring, on account of his upcoming nuptials. So, lifelong friends Hogan, Bob, Chilli (Johnson) and Sable (Buress) crash Jerry’s wedding, ready to end his streak.

Mike and Dave Need Wedding Dates was the last major comedy inspired by real-life bros, but it was smart enough to sideline its titular, date-seeking dudes and instead showcase Aubrey Plaza and Anna Kendrick. Tag, unfortunately, doesn’t do the same, benching the firecracker Isla Fisher, who plays Hogan’s supportive wife Anna. She's excluded from tag because the men say she’s "intense". Apparently, girls always play the game wrong, even when they’re playing along.

There is at least some effort made to acknowledge how Tag is cashing in on the trope of 'nagging' wives in boys-club comedies. (Bibb, doing heroic work as Jerry’s fiancée, politely warns the gang through a gritted smile not to ruin her wedding, saying she doesn’t want to be "that woman", adding, reasonably, that being "that woman" in these circumstances is actually very understandable.) But where’s the justification for what Tag does to Rashida Jones, who participates—barely—in a romantic subplot so confusing and misshapen I still can’t wrap my head around it.

Most of the cast suffers individually. Renner broke both arms performing a stunt, and is miscast as the troupe’s icy cool leader. (Remember, he is canonically the least cool Avenger, and that’s counting Paul Bettany.) Helms, lumped with a bleak twist that is nonetheless telegraphed heavily, had funnier material to work with in Chappaquiddick. Johnson, as a go-nowhere stoner, gets the laziest punchlines (“Well, that happened”). And Buress, who is normally such a treat in Broad City, has his deadpan delivery murdered by Tomsic’s frantic direction.

Then, after all of this, Tag zigs with a wildly misjudged comedic tangent in the final act that makes a lame film actively distasteful. And Tag is not a 'black comedy'; it’s far too earnest for the kind of subversion it's supposedly striving for. It’s just a 'sad comedy', in that I was bummed out the whole time watching it.

I suppose this is our punishment for not properly appreciating Game Night, a devious and surprisingly cinematic picture that was funny, sometimes. That’s the bar Tag needed to clear, and can't.

But, if someone came to me very specifically seeking a movie with a 'tag' themed title that’ll make them laugh… well, no, I’d still recommend It first.

2/5

In Australian cinemas now. Rated M for crude sexual humour, coarse language and drug use.

Photo: Roadshow

Most Popular

Comments & Feedback

Share your opinion

Emoji cheatsheet    Formatting    Comment guidelines