Movie Review: Colin Firth Cheats His Way Around the Globe in So-Strange-It’s-True Tale "The Mercy"

Colin Firth plays a real-life amateur sailor who embarked on an all-time unusual trip around the globe in The Mercy.
Have you heard the one about amateur sailor Donald Crowhurst and his attempt to circumnavigate the globe? Then you’re probably wondering how director James Marsh could possibly make a movie of it.
If you haven’t, you might see The Mercy expecting a sterling adventure flick; a right-royal knees-up!
Yeah, it ain’t that.
I won’t spoil the true events surrounding Crowhurst’s 1968 voyage, though they’re easily Googleable, and have certainly passed into the realm of legend for his story’s unusual—even chilling—resolution.
It’s a strange and tragic parcel of trivia at best (see also: American Made; The Disaster Artist; Gold), and any attempt to expand it to 100 minutes seemed like a hubristic undertaking of a hubristic undertaking.
Would you believe Marsh pulls off his miraculous feat, turning Crowhurst’s highly-disturbing story into something worthwhile, and worth watching?
He’s helped along by Colin Firth, who plays Crowhurst as a silver-tongued salesman who’s entirely out of his element on the open seas, and who can never quite shut himself up. (Compare that to the almost-silent Robert Redford in All is Lost; though, they share one thing in common: dropping an unholy F-bomb out of frustration when things get curly out on the water.)
Crowhurst, seeking glory, signed up for a race around the world to compete against professionals with his self-designed vessel and navigational system, attracting sponsors—and a PR person (the reliable David Thewlis)—eager to ride the coattails of an underdog. But when preparations for his trip take too long, his financial commitments force him into the water unready, where he must hide his pangs of fear—and his boat’s worsening body—from his wife Clare (Rachel Weisz) and three children or face the worst outcome of all: shame. So, he begins cheating. And that’s not nearly the end of it.

Whether it’s thanks to Firth’s performance, screenwriter’s Scott Z. Burns’ dialogue on the page, or adherence to the actual Donald's personality, Crowhurst is smartly depicted here as a classic hero of British cinema, armed with a stiff upper lip and a witty retort for every situation. It’s what the picture does to him—and that archetype—next that buoys The Mercy.
I certainly had my doubts about Marsh’s abilities, especially after his last effort at the helm: the spiritual black hole that is the Stephen Hawking biopic The Theory of Everything, which was heaped with baffling acclaim. Thankfully, Marsh returns to his natural roots here, harking back to his stylised documentaries about weirdos and their primal obsessions (Man on Wire, Project Nim). He also makes good on the promise of his earlier—and similarly morose thriller—narrative feature, Shadow Dancer.
If anything, The Mercy is an inversion of faux-inspirational fare like The Theory of Everything, setting up a frightfully-well-mannered English adventure for all the family, and then ending on the cusp of human despair and religious mania. Even the late, great composer Jóhann Jóhannsson—with one of his last scores—follows suit, beginning with the same kind of swirling, twinkling compositions that won him a Golden Globe for Theory, before turning to sparser, more alienating fare.
The Mercy is no day at the beach, and certainly by the time the picture arrives at its own title (yes, this is one of those films that actually says its own name), viewers will likely be stressed to the max from Crowhurst’s unending, nauseating sea-struggles (captured by cinematographer Éric Gautier).
However, by that point, Marsh has lulled us into this compelling crusade, and both Firth and especially Weisz have given us humane portraits of sympathetic people in an uncommon scenario. And with the exception of a final, furious and ill-fated monologue by Weisz that confusingly gives everyone from the media to English people in general a spray, The Mercy always remains afloat.
3.5/5
In Australian cinemas now. Rated M for coarse language.
Photo: Studio Canal
Topics
Ref: 270f0e52-fc24-4c37-83ca-a89d001521a2
Most Popular
Comments & Feedback
Share your opinion







No Comments just yet
Check back later to see what others are saying , or you can be the first to leave a comment!