J.K. Rowling Still Insists Quidditch "Makes Total Sense", Even Though, Nah

For two decades, J.K. Rowling has remained in denial about the baffling scoring system to her invented sport of Quidditch.
Most say the chase for the Golden Snitch (worth 150 points) is pointless, while others argue it would be smartest to field a whole team of Seekers that spend the match pursuing it.
If the scores tighten, sure, play some defence, but the game only ends when you catch the Snitch anyway. It may not be the most sporting approach, but a win is a win.
(If none of this makes any sense to you, why did you click on an article about Quidditch anyway?)

Whatever your specific issue with Quidditch, Rowling has had just about enough of these critiques, and recently responded to a Twitter complaint that "the scoring system of quidditch makes zero sense".
It makes total sense. There's glamour in chasing an elusive lucky break, but teamwork and persistence can still win the day. Everyone's vulnerable to blows of fate and obstructive people, and success means rising above them. Quidditch is the human condition. You're welcome. pic.twitter.com/0VYCgo13xh
— J.K. Rowling (@jk_rowling) October 9, 2018
She offered up a not-great argument, saying the game represented "the human condition," following it with the most passive aggressive "you’re welcome" we’ve ever seen from a YA author.
However, she mercifully didn't direct reply to her critic, sparing their mentions.
Some supported Rowling, while other Bludgers saw right through it:
I still dont like the scoring system. If a team is down by over 150 points they have 0 incentive to go for the snitch, as they would lose if they caught it.
— CoachZetsu (@Zetsubonokami) October 9, 2018
Just because something is a good literary devise doesn’t make it a good system of rules
— Steph (@yellowcrone) October 9, 2018
150 points gives too much importance to the snitch and seekers and makes the other players more or less irrelevant except for in extreme cases
— Shaun Shaikh (@shaunshaikh) October 9, 2018
Teamwork and persistence can "STILL" win the day? No.
— Kaustubh Varshney (@KaustubhVarshne) October 10, 2018
It wins a LOT more than "elusive lucky breaks". There is no glamour in chasing luck.
I love the Harry Potter series with all my heart but some of these tweets..... Come on Joanne, you can admit your mistakes.
All this argument proves is that while there remains breath on this Earthly plane, there will be arguments about Quidditch.

Header Image: Warner Bros. Pictures
Topics
Ref: eecc3caf-e93c-4d7b-8996-a976001bb5a6
Most Popular
Comments & Feedback
Share your opinion







No Comments just yet
Check back later to see what others are saying , or you can be the first to leave a comment!